I commented early on while watching The Pitt that in Taylor Dearden’s character, Dr. Melissa King, we have the best representation of neurodivergence I’ve ever seen on television – and nothing about the rest of the season changed my mind.
A New Standard for Neurodivergent Characters
In Hollywood, neurodivergence is often portrayed in reductive ways. Characters are either emotionally flat to the point of sociopathy, or quirky sidekicks written for comic relief. These depictions rarely ring true for people who actually live with neurodivergent minds.
But with Dr. Melissa King in The Pitt, we finally get something different: a fully realised, deeply human character who happens to be neurodivergent.
She’s a knowledge sponge – precise, observant, and often brilliant under pressure. She experiences imposter syndrome, even when she’s clearly one of the most capable people in the room. She’s empathetic, even though she sometimes struggles with social nuance. And importantly, she is never reduced to her diagnosis – because no diagnosis is ever explicitly given. She just is.
Grounded in Reality, Not Labels
The beauty of Dr. King’s character is that the show never treats her neurodivergence as a plot twist or teaching moment. There’s no monologue revealing a childhood struggle, no flashbacks to trauma, no big reveal. Her character development happens in the present – through dialogue, action, and interaction with her colleagues.
In episode 2, for example, she casually mentions having an autistic sister. It’s a blink-and-you-miss-it moment, but one that adds depth and quietly informs the way she navigates the world around her. It gives context to her empathy and her need for clarity, without reducing her to a personal history or backstory.
Played with Precision and Care
Taylor Dearden’s performance is exceptional. She doesn’t play Dr. King with theatrical tics or overblown quirks. Instead, she uses subtlety: a pause before answering, a hyper-literal interpretation of a question, a carefully rehearsed phrase delivered with just a bit too much intensity.
These moments feel familiar to anyone who has experienced or lived alongside neurodivergence. They aren’t exaggerated. They’re just real.
More importantly, the show doesn’t use these traits as punchlines. It lets us sit with them. Sometimes they lead to awkward moments; other times, they help save lives. The show trusts the audience to interpret her character without needing everything spelled out.
An Ensemble That Makes Room for Difference
The Pitt is an ensemble series set in a Pittsburgh trauma ward. At its center is Dr. “Robby” Robinavitch, played by Noah Wyle, whose mentorship of the younger staff is understated but impactful. He doesn’t treat Dr. King as someone to fix. He treats her as a colleague – with high expectations and room to grow.
That might sound like a small thing, but in a world where neurodivergent people are often underestimated or micromanaged, it matters. He respects her intellect, acknowledges her awkwardness, and trusts her judgment when it counts.
The rest of the ensemble is equally well-drawn, each character given space to be competent and flawed in their own way. There’s no “normal” baseline here – just a collection of messy, passionate people trying to do their jobs under impossible pressure.
Imposter Syndrome in the ER
One of the most relatable aspects of Dr. King’s character is her internal battle with imposter syndrome. Even when she’s technically right – and she often is – she hesitates. She second-guesses. She asks if she’s doing enough, being enough, or if she’s even meant to be in this line of work.
This isn’t presented as a dramatic weakness. It’s just part of her day-to-day life. And it reflects the experience of many neurodivergent professionals, who grow up being told they’re “too much” or “not enough” – sometimes both at once.
Her arc is not about “fixing” that insecurity. It’s about learning to function alongside it. She doesn’t have a grand moment of triumph. She just keeps showing up. Keeps trying. Keeps being excellent, even when she’s unsure.
That quiet perseverance is one of the most powerful parts of her story.
Representation Done Right
What’s revolutionary about Dr. King’s character isn’t that she’s neurodivergent – it’s that she’s neurodivergent and respected. And trusted. And flawed. And brilliant. She’s not boxed in by a diagnosis. She’s allowed to be complicated.
We rarely see neurodivergent women on television portrayed with this much care and nuance. When we do see autistic or ADHD-coded characters, they’re usually male, and usually filtered through the lens of genius. Dr. King, by contrast, is grounded. She’s real.
She isn’t quirky or savant-like. She doesn’t solve every problem with a magical insight. She’s just doing her best, one trauma call at a time, with her heart in the right place and her brain working overtime.
A Word on Realism (and Gore)
The Pitt doesn’t pull punches.
The trauma cases are graphic. Injuries are shown in full, sometimes with brutal accuracy. If blood, broken limbs, or medical procedures are triggering for you, this show may not be your ideal comfort watch.
But none of it is gratuitous. The realism serves a purpose – it mirrors the emotional stakes, the chaos, the very real cost of medical care in an underfunded, overburdened system. It gives weight to every decision the characters make.
And in the midst of all that, it gives us space to connect with these people as people – not just doctors, nurses, or patients, but whole human beings trying to do right by one another.
Final Thoughts
If The Pitt has one overarching message, it’s that there’s more than one way to be human – and more than one way to help. Dr. Melissa King embodies that beautifully.
She doesn’t need a redemption arc. She doesn’t need to become more “normal.” She just needs what all of us need: respect, understanding, and a chance to do what she does best.
For those who’ve waited a long time to see characters who think, speak, and struggle like they do, The Pitt is a gift. It proves that neurodivergent people don’t have to be sidelined or simplified. They can be the heart of the story – and in Dr. King’s case, they often are.
Leave a Reply